Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Expos Toujours!'s avatar

A few comments - first, harkening back to the underlying measure of "success." Now that Dave Roberts is the new Mr. Regular Season titleholder (dismissing the ridiculous 2020 "championship" as worthy of equality with the others), we may ask the value of a managerial career with lots of regular season wins and longevity. Does one need a WS title? Baker is HOF, but not Tom Kelly? Why? Not a desperately perceived dropoff in interest from black Americans, is it? These are legitimate questions, especially for our current crop of craven team owners. Or is success merely participating in lots of increasingly devalued regular season games? The regurgitation of personnel in pro sports might be all about hard-to-get experience. Yet, I think the answer is obvious. Baker (and Roberts, when his time comes) is a HOFer because baseball must acclaim and prop up the value of the regular season, especially within its tightly closed (incestuous?) ranks. So, yes, MLB collectively genuflected in thanks when Baker won with the Astros. This is exactly the same requisite legitimacy stamp they needed for Fishbowl 2020, the Dodgers, and anointed prince Roberts. As I have noted before, it takes very little imagination to hear the shrill howling of illegitimacy (and demands for the dreaded asterisk) had the Marlins won the 2020 "championship." As we continue to see, modern MLB owners will literally create any rationale and twist any rules necessary to achieve both self-validation of their marketing-based decisions and profitability. No problem with profit, per se. We're soon to see NASCAR-esque uniforms, ABS, howls for female field managers, lowering of historical HOF criteria (after all, we can't have a year without an electee, can we?), expansion (there's plenty of major league talent, of course), and more. I'm sure it's all for the best because they love the game. Yeah.

Expand full comment
Michelle L's avatar

Isn’t the chart in the Athletic wrong? The marlins won the World Series in 2003 and not 2013. Am I reading this story wrong?

Expand full comment
3 more comments...

No posts